In a thrilling United Rugby Championship clash, the Lions staged a dramatic 22-23 comeback victory over the Sharks in Durban, leaving fans on the edge of their seats. But here's where it gets controversial: while the Lions celebrated a hard-fought win, one player’s momentary lapse in judgment nearly cost them the game. Let’s dive into the player ratings and dissect the highs, lows, and everything in between.
Lions Player Ratings: A Tale of Resilience and Near-Disaster
15 Quan Horn (6): The ever-reliable last line of defense, Horn consistently bailed his team out of trouble. His ability to add an extra dimension to the Lions’ attack proved crucial in bypassing the Sharks’ relentless press. A solid performance from the fullback.
14 Kelly Mpeku (6): Under constant pressure from Grant Williams’ precise box kicks, Mpeku truly shone when given space to run with the ball. His defensive efforts were commendable, though not without room for improvement.
13 Erich Cronje (7): The Lions’ centers held their own against the formidable Springboks duo of Andre Esterhuizen and Ethan Hooker. Cronje’s defensive prowess and smart decision-making with the ball were standout features, though his line breaks added further value.
12 Bronson Mills (8): In a head-to-head battle against Esterhuizen, Mills emerged victorious. His defensive tenacity, varied attacking play, and intelligent kicking—gaining over 40 meters and beating six defenders—made him a key figure in the Lions’ success. At just 22, he’s knocking loudly on the door for a Test call-up.
11 Angelo Davids (5): Despite being outpaced by Edwill van der Merwe, Davids made his mark with ball in hand. However, aerial challenges remain a weakness, though his overall contribution was adequate.
10 Chris Smith (6): Like his counterpart Jordan Hendrikse, Smith struggled with kicking accuracy but delivered when it mattered most, steering the Lions to victory with a competent kicking game. His supporting role was instrumental in marshaling the team.
9 Morne van den Berg (6): While maintaining the tempo of the Lions’ attack, van den Berg’s misplaced and mistimed kicks squandered several opportunities. Still, the Springbok number nine’s performance was far from poor.
Sharks Player Ratings: A Mix of Brilliance and Uncharacteristic Errors
Forwards
8 Francke Horn (c) (7): The captain’s try was a highlight, showcasing his effectiveness in both attack and defense. His partnership with the loose trio was a bright spot in an otherwise challenging match.
7 Ruan Venter (4): Venter’s performance was a rollercoaster. His stunning break and offload set up Horn’s try, but a reckless hit on Aphelele Fassi earned him a red card, leaving his team a man down. And this is the part most people miss: his brain explosion could have cost the Sharks the game, were it not for the bench’s heroic efforts.
6 Jarod Cairns (5): Despite strong carries, Cairns missed four tackles, raising questions about his defensive reliability. His average performance led to an early substitution in the 65th minute.
5 Ruben Schoeman (5): While effective in the rucks, Schoeman shares the blame for the misfiring lineout. His impact was limited, resulting in an early exit at the hour mark.
4 Etienne Oosthuizen (6): A mixed bag from Oosthuizen, who scored a try but gifted the Sharks a penalty with a foolish push on Fassi. His performance was a blend of brilliance and blunders.
3 Asenathi Ntlabakanye (8): A standout performer, Ntlabakanye’s defensive hits and ability to draw defenders were pivotal. His scrum battle against Ox Nche was a highlight, showcasing his growth as a tighthead.
2 PJ Botha (6): While not solely responsible for the lineout issues, Botha’s performance in this area was concerning. His defensive efforts, including a key turnover, redeemed an otherwise average showing.
1 Eddie Davids (5): A quiet but steady performance from Davids, who conceded a scrum penalty but held his own in the set-piece.
Replacements: The Unsung Heroes
After a strong start, the Lions’ collapse gifted the Sharks the lead, forcing the bench to step up. Siba Qoma stood out, but it was Haashim Pead, the Junior Bok superstar, who stole the show. His match-winning try at the death cemented his status as the hero of the day, capping off an influential performance.
Food for Thought
As we reflect on this nail-biting encounter, one can’t help but wonder: How would the game have unfolded if Venter had kept his cool? And with Bronson Mills knocking on the door, is a Test call-up on the horizon? Let us know your thoughts in the comments—do you agree with our ratings, or do you see it differently? The debate is open!
For more in-depth rugby analysis and coverage you can trust, add Planet Rugby to your preferred sources on Google. And don’t miss our latest feature: Percy Montgomery revisits World Cup-ending ban and why Eben Etzebeth is ‘lucky’. The conversation starts here—join in!
