Here’s a bold statement: Elly De La Cruz is not just another baseball player—he’s a phenomenon. At just 21 years old, he burst onto the Major League scene in 2023, defying the odds and becoming one of the youngest players to make their debut in recent memory. Fast forward to 2025, and the hype around this Cincinnati Reds shortstop shows no signs of slowing down. But here’s where it gets controversial: while some see him as a future MVP, others argue he still has hurdles to clear. Let’s dive in.
Earlier this week, Bleacher Report released its highly anticipated list of the top 25 athletes under 25, and De La Cruz secured the No. 21 spot. Joel Reuter, a writer for Bleacher Report, highlighted his impressive first-half stats from the 2025 season: a .284/.359/.495 batting line, 18 home runs, 25 steals, and a manageable 24.3% strikeout rate. However, Reuter noted a noticeable dip in production after the All-Star break, raising questions about endurance in the grueling six-month MLB season. And this is the part most people miss: while his 2025 performance wasn’t flawless, it’s his potential ceiling that has experts buzzing. As Reuter put it, ‘Others are a safer bet to be superstars for the next decade, but De La Cruz's ceiling stacks up to anyone on this list.’
Off the field, De La Cruz has become the Reds’ most marketable player in years. In 2025, he graced the cover of MLB The Show alongside stars like Paul Skenes and Gunnar Henderson—a testament to his rising star power. Yet, despite his slight on-field setback in 2025, there’s every reason to believe he’ll bounce back stronger in 2026. After all, at just 23, he’s still years away from reaching his prime.
Here’s the controversial question: Is De La Cruz’s potential being overhyped, or is he truly on the path to becoming an MLB legend? Let’s not forget, the transition from promising talent to consistent superstar is rarely a straight line. But if he can figure out how to sustain his performance over a full season, the sky’s the limit.
For those eager to keep up with De La Cruz and the Reds, bookmark Cincinnati Reds Talk for the latest news, exclusive interviews, and daily coverage. And while you’re at it, check out their full list of top athletes under 25 here.
Don’t miss out on other Reds-related stories, like the under-the-radar prospect making waves in the Arizona Fall League here, or the team’s historic postseason struggles here.
Follow Cincinnati Reds on SI on Twitter/X @RedsTalkSI, like their Facebook page here, and subscribe to the ONLY Daily Reds Podcast here. Stay connected on Instagram here for more insider updates.
So, what’s your take? Is Elly De La Cruz the real deal, or is the hype getting ahead of reality? Let us know in the comments—we’re all ears!
